- Posts: 1
- Thank you received: 0
Mid Carpal instability
-
- Visitor
-
14 years 10 months ago #29340
by
Replied by on topic Re:Mid Carpal instability
Hi Adie....
My mother had a Mid Carpal operation about 6 years ago when she was in her 70s..
It has been a complete success and with little to no reaction.
She was told that the physio after-care was really important in improving recovery.
All the best xx Tony 
<br><br>Post edited by: Scott_1984, at: 2009/12/29 04:19
My mother had a Mid Carpal operation about 6 years ago when she was in her 70s..
It has been a complete success and with little to no reaction.
She was told that the physio after-care was really important in improving recovery.
All the best xx Tony <br><br>Post edited by: Scott_1984, at: 2009/12/29 04:19 Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Scott_1984
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
14 years 10 months ago #29354
by Scott_1984
Replied by Scott_1984 on topic Re:Mid Carpal instability
Hi Adie
Mid Carpal Instability (MCI) can be very complex for the consultant orthopeadic & trauma & hand upper-limb surgeon/s,
Some debate its not a disability, condition, &/Or a problem, & They say MCI is in Your head or a party-trick, or You've got hyper mobility syndrome, & These Consultants are often lazy & lack knowlodge, & State X-Rays & MRI-Scans reveal no instability patterns or arthritis, & They therefore see no problems, But most Wrist Instability Patterns at the being is Dynamic & Therefore will never show up on Stand Plan X-Rays, MRI-Scans, It can take serval weeks, months, & Even sometimes many years for Static Wrist Instability Patterns to show up on plan X-rays & MRI-Scans,
When Wrist Instability is in the early diagnoise, You Consultant has to relie on Special Test X-Rays & MRI-Scans, But mainly The Consultant has to relie on \"PHYSICAL TESTS & EXAMINATIONS OF THE FINGERS, HAND, WRIST, ARM, ELBOW, SHOULDER, NECK\" \"AND TAKING A DETAILED HISTORY\".
Each Wrist Instability Pattern will be dealt differently by each Consultant, An Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, Will always try to be honest with there patients & explain that MCI is Complex & Serious, & Will in its self bring rise to complactions,
That might include the mci being ignored for years, referred from Doctors, Consultants, Hospitals, Physiotherapists, & Being let done, etc.
But once Your in the hands of a Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, Will always try to be honest with there patients & explain that MCI is Complex & Serious, & They will often advise twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, followed by 6 - 8 weeks in a wrist splint/brace, hot & cold therapy for pain & swelling, Painkillers & NSAIDs, Then followed by Special Stress X-rays, The best MRI-Scanners, Physical Examinaton of both sets of fingers, hands, wrists, arms, elbows, shoulders, both sides of the neck, (This is to rule out hpyer mobility snydrome),
Once all these tests have been studied & If after 6 - 8 weeks in a wrist splint/wrist brace, twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, Painkillers & NSAIDs,, hot & cold therapy, Has not helped with the Wrist Instability Pain, Discomfort, Clicking, snapping, clunking, popping,
Then The Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, Will discuss optitions, So of which will be try to live with the mci for life without any operations, Or discuss many operations,
They often will not ccarry out a limited or full wwrist fusion on young people, Sometimes not on people in there 70's,
So young people are often left with living with the mci for live without wrist spints/wrist braces, hot & cold therapy for pain & swelling, Painkillers & NSAIDs, & Then carrying on with twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, for life,
Or live with the mci & Carry on with all the above for live & Without Any Wrist Stablizing Operations, & Carry on with wrist spints/wrist braces, hot & cold therapy for pain & swelling, Painkillers & NSAIDs, & Then carrying on with twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, for life, (You'll Always Be told Not To Over Use the Wrist That Has MCI, But At The Same Time To Also Never Stop Using The MCI Wrist Either),
Young often will only be given the following standard stabilizing mci operations:
* Wrist Arthroscopy *
* Ligament Tightening Operation & May Use K-Wires To Fix/Stablize A Few Unstable Carpal Bones For Few Weeks, While In Wrist Cast For 3 Months or So *
* Arthroscopic Thermal Capsulorrhaphy for Palmar Midcarpal Instability *
All those mci stablizing wrist operations do not carry any sort of Guarantee of ever working to stablize the carpal bones or being a life time fix for Pain & Discomfort, & After the go ahead You must continue with wrist spints/wrist braces, hot & cold therapy for pain & swelling, Painkillers & NSAIDs, & Then carrying on with twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, for life.
Most of those 3 standard wrist operations for mci can be hit & Miss, Depending on the level of the carpal instability patterns & Other complactions, Such as developing RSD/CRSP, Or other nevere damge, or carpal tunnel syndrome, & So on can all effect the outcome of such an mci stablizing wrist operation, & Were to go if the above treatments have failed, etc,
All though any of the above 3 opertions could last for years, They often will need a limited &/Or a full wrist fusion, Which most Suregons refuse to carry out on the young, Let alone the old,
Those who get a limited &/Or a full wrist fusion are often luck, But still have to carry out physiotherapy & May need splints, aids, & painkillers, But in the long furture & depending on your job/s & hobbies, the limited or full fusion could later out added pressure on the joints that are now supporting the wrist with the plate or someing the size of a fifty penece holding the carpal bones together, & Some develope RSD/CRSP, Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, Other nevere damage,
&
Then if You get other disabilities/conditons on top of Your already Pianful MCI, & Other outside factors, The Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, May no longer want to go ahead with a Your best opition/s of a successfuk out come & More use from Your wrist, & Decide its to risky to go ahead with an limited &/Or full wrist fusion to stablize the carpal bones & Even though its Your best shot, They won't go ahead with it, So Your stuck or left to Struggle on.
I Suggest Pain Managerment too.
Adie You might want to chat with Myself, Julie, & Ryan, @ www.ablehere.com/component/option,com_jo...iew/id,2097/catid,47 & www.ablehere.com/component/option,com_jo...ew/id,15798/catid,47
They might be able to discuss about there views/opinions on mci & How they've been treated, etc.
You can read Micks thread, Sadly His not been on Ablehere.Com in ages & I am slightly worried about Him, As the last time we spoke, He seemed very depressed/low, His thread @ www.ablehere.com/component/option,com_jo...iew/id,5675/catid,47
My Website/Story Can Be Found At: reynolds1984.multiply.com
&
For places to go for informaton on: Wrist Instability, Carpal Instability, Mid Carpal Instability (MCI)/Palmar Midcarpal Instability (PMCI) & By Many Other Names, Visit My Online Support Group For MCI/PMCI, RSD/CRSP 1&2, & Other Upper-Limb DisaBilities, Visit: wristinstability.multiply.com
Hope this helps & Sorry for typing, spelling.
Sounds like Tony Your Mum had a good outcome
Scott
Take Care & Take It Easy
Happy Holidays
Mid Carpal Instability (MCI) can be very complex for the consultant orthopeadic & trauma & hand upper-limb surgeon/s,
Some debate its not a disability, condition, &/Or a problem, & They say MCI is in Your head or a party-trick, or You've got hyper mobility syndrome, & These Consultants are often lazy & lack knowlodge, & State X-Rays & MRI-Scans reveal no instability patterns or arthritis, & They therefore see no problems, But most Wrist Instability Patterns at the being is Dynamic & Therefore will never show up on Stand Plan X-Rays, MRI-Scans, It can take serval weeks, months, & Even sometimes many years for Static Wrist Instability Patterns to show up on plan X-rays & MRI-Scans,
When Wrist Instability is in the early diagnoise, You Consultant has to relie on Special Test X-Rays & MRI-Scans, But mainly The Consultant has to relie on \"PHYSICAL TESTS & EXAMINATIONS OF THE FINGERS, HAND, WRIST, ARM, ELBOW, SHOULDER, NECK\" \"AND TAKING A DETAILED HISTORY\".
Each Wrist Instability Pattern will be dealt differently by each Consultant, An Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, Will always try to be honest with there patients & explain that MCI is Complex & Serious, & Will in its self bring rise to complactions,
That might include the mci being ignored for years, referred from Doctors, Consultants, Hospitals, Physiotherapists, & Being let done, etc.
But once Your in the hands of a Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, Will always try to be honest with there patients & explain that MCI is Complex & Serious, & They will often advise twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, followed by 6 - 8 weeks in a wrist splint/brace, hot & cold therapy for pain & swelling, Painkillers & NSAIDs, Then followed by Special Stress X-rays, The best MRI-Scanners, Physical Examinaton of both sets of fingers, hands, wrists, arms, elbows, shoulders, both sides of the neck, (This is to rule out hpyer mobility snydrome),
Once all these tests have been studied & If after 6 - 8 weeks in a wrist splint/wrist brace, twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, Painkillers & NSAIDs,, hot & cold therapy, Has not helped with the Wrist Instability Pain, Discomfort, Clicking, snapping, clunking, popping,
Then The Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, Will discuss optitions, So of which will be try to live with the mci for life without any operations, Or discuss many operations,
They often will not ccarry out a limited or full wwrist fusion on young people, Sometimes not on people in there 70's,
So young people are often left with living with the mci for live without wrist spints/wrist braces, hot & cold therapy for pain & swelling, Painkillers & NSAIDs, & Then carrying on with twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, for life,
Or live with the mci & Carry on with all the above for live & Without Any Wrist Stablizing Operations, & Carry on with wrist spints/wrist braces, hot & cold therapy for pain & swelling, Painkillers & NSAIDs, & Then carrying on with twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, for life, (You'll Always Be told Not To Over Use the Wrist That Has MCI, But At The Same Time To Also Never Stop Using The MCI Wrist Either),
Young often will only be given the following standard stabilizing mci operations:
* Wrist Arthroscopy *
* Ligament Tightening Operation & May Use K-Wires To Fix/Stablize A Few Unstable Carpal Bones For Few Weeks, While In Wrist Cast For 3 Months or So *
* Arthroscopic Thermal Capsulorrhaphy for Palmar Midcarpal Instability *
All those mci stablizing wrist operations do not carry any sort of Guarantee of ever working to stablize the carpal bones or being a life time fix for Pain & Discomfort, & After the go ahead You must continue with wrist spints/wrist braces, hot & cold therapy for pain & swelling, Painkillers & NSAIDs, & Then carrying on with twice a day physiotherapy finger, hand, wrist, arm, strenthening exercises, for life.
Most of those 3 standard wrist operations for mci can be hit & Miss, Depending on the level of the carpal instability patterns & Other complactions, Such as developing RSD/CRSP, Or other nevere damge, or carpal tunnel syndrome, & So on can all effect the outcome of such an mci stablizing wrist operation, & Were to go if the above treatments have failed, etc,
All though any of the above 3 opertions could last for years, They often will need a limited &/Or a full wrist fusion, Which most Suregons refuse to carry out on the young, Let alone the old,
Those who get a limited &/Or a full wrist fusion are often luck, But still have to carry out physiotherapy & May need splints, aids, & painkillers, But in the long furture & depending on your job/s & hobbies, the limited or full fusion could later out added pressure on the joints that are now supporting the wrist with the plate or someing the size of a fifty penece holding the carpal bones together, & Some develope RSD/CRSP, Carpal Tunnel Syndrome, Other nevere damage,
&
Then if You get other disabilities/conditons on top of Your already Pianful MCI, & Other outside factors, The Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, May no longer want to go ahead with a Your best opition/s of a successfuk out come & More use from Your wrist, & Decide its to risky to go ahead with an limited &/Or full wrist fusion to stablize the carpal bones & Even though its Your best shot, They won't go ahead with it, So Your stuck or left to Struggle on.
I Suggest Pain Managerment too.
Adie You might want to chat with Myself, Julie, & Ryan, @ www.ablehere.com/component/option,com_jo...iew/id,2097/catid,47 & www.ablehere.com/component/option,com_jo...ew/id,15798/catid,47
They might be able to discuss about there views/opinions on mci & How they've been treated, etc.
You can read Micks thread, Sadly His not been on Ablehere.Com in ages & I am slightly worried about Him, As the last time we spoke, He seemed very depressed/low, His thread @ www.ablehere.com/component/option,com_jo...iew/id,5675/catid,47
My Website/Story Can Be Found At: reynolds1984.multiply.com
&
For places to go for informaton on: Wrist Instability, Carpal Instability, Mid Carpal Instability (MCI)/Palmar Midcarpal Instability (PMCI) & By Many Other Names, Visit My Online Support Group For MCI/PMCI, RSD/CRSP 1&2, & Other Upper-Limb DisaBilities, Visit: wristinstability.multiply.com
Hope this helps & Sorry for typing, spelling.
Sounds like Tony Your Mum had a good outcome
Scott
Take Care & Take It Easy
Happy Holidays
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Scott_1984
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
14 years 10 months ago #29355
by Scott_1984
Replied by Scott_1984 on topic Re:Mid Carpal instability
tonypark wrote:
Hi Tony
May ask what type of MCI Stablizing Wrist Operation She went under?.
Was She under an Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, Or was She under another type of Consultant Surgeon &/Or An General Consultant Surgeon?.
How long was it before The MCI had been diagionsed, Before they operated?.
Was She at point told The MCI was in Her head, A Party-Trick, Been there all Her life & She'd never noticed it &/Or never caused Her Pian, Discomfort, Disability, Or Any point suggest She had hyper mobility snydrome?.
Was She treated first through 6 - 8 weeks in a wrist splint/wrist brace, with physiotherapy, painkillers, ect, While MRI-Scans & Stress X-Rays & Physical Examinations were taking place, Or did they \"JUMP STRAIGHT INTO SURGERY BECAUSE OF HER AGE & WRIST DISABILITY\"?.
Were they any signs of arthritis in the hand/wrist.
Was She told any MCI Stablizing Wrist Operation Doesn't Equal A Cure/Fix, But Might Help For 8 - 10 Years, Depending On The Type Of Wrist Operation Carried Out.
Sorry for type o' s & Spelling mistakes
I am looking forward to hearing loads of replies from The Ablehere.Com Group/Family,
As I Know We As An Online Group/Family On: Ablehere.Com We Have A Few Mid Carpal Instability Suffers From All Around The World & Diffent Ages & Sexies,
So Adie, You Should Find Alot Of Help, Advice, & Support, & Understanding & Knowledge In Mid Carpal Instability (MCI)Palmar Midcarpal Instability (PMCI) & Wrist Instability/Carpal Instability Suffers & Support From Patients/Suffers.
Take Care & Take It Easy
Scott (Scott_1984)
Hi Adie....
My mother had a Mid Carpal operation about 6 years ago when she was in her 70s..
It has been a complete success and with little to no reaction.
She was told that the physio after-care was really important in improving recovery.
Hi Tony
May ask what type of MCI Stablizing Wrist Operation She went under?.
Was She under an Exprinced Consultant Orthopeadic & Trauma & Hand Upper-Limb Surgeon/s, Or was She under another type of Consultant Surgeon &/Or An General Consultant Surgeon?.
How long was it before The MCI had been diagionsed, Before they operated?.
Was She at point told The MCI was in Her head, A Party-Trick, Been there all Her life & She'd never noticed it &/Or never caused Her Pian, Discomfort, Disability, Or Any point suggest She had hyper mobility snydrome?.
Was She treated first through 6 - 8 weeks in a wrist splint/wrist brace, with physiotherapy, painkillers, ect, While MRI-Scans & Stress X-Rays & Physical Examinations were taking place, Or did they \"JUMP STRAIGHT INTO SURGERY BECAUSE OF HER AGE & WRIST DISABILITY\"?.
Were they any signs of arthritis in the hand/wrist.
Was She told any MCI Stablizing Wrist Operation Doesn't Equal A Cure/Fix, But Might Help For 8 - 10 Years, Depending On The Type Of Wrist Operation Carried Out.
Sorry for type o' s & Spelling mistakes
I am looking forward to hearing loads of replies from The Ablehere.Com Group/Family,
As I Know We As An Online Group/Family On: Ablehere.Com We Have A Few Mid Carpal Instability Suffers From All Around The World & Diffent Ages & Sexies,
So Adie, You Should Find Alot Of Help, Advice, & Support, & Understanding & Knowledge In Mid Carpal Instability (MCI)Palmar Midcarpal Instability (PMCI) & Wrist Instability/Carpal Instability Suffers & Support From Patients/Suffers.
Take Care & Take It Easy
Scott (Scott_1984)
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Scott_1984
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
- Scott_1984
-
- Offline
- Moderator
-
14 years 10 months ago #29357
by Scott_1984
Replied by Scott_1984 on topic Re:Mid Carpal instability
Hi again Adie & Ablehere.Com Group/Family
It also sounds like from Your Penpal Blog type thing, That You could also be suffering from hyper mobility snydrome, & I believe You shoud ask if You'll benefit seeing An \"HYPER MOBILITY SNYDROME SPECIALIST & PAIN SPECIALIST\"
\"AS THEY MIGHT REFER YOU TO SPECIAL PHYSIOTHERAPY STRENTHENING EXERCISES & HELP PAIN MANAGERMENT TECHQUIES, & SO ON\"
Julie maybe able to advise on Hyper Mobility Syndrome.
This NHS Hopsital Offers Pain Managerment - General: www.nhs.uk/ServiceDirectories/Pages/hospital.aspx?id=RBT20
&
Full Lists At: www.nhs.uk/ServiceDirectories/Pages/trust.aspx?id=RBT&v=1
I'm amazed they have there own hand/wrist only clinics in orthopeadics & Even Elbow Only Clinics IN orthopeadics, I've not come across that before, LOL
www.ablehere.com/index.php?option=com_bookjoomlas
It also sounds like from Your Penpal Blog type thing, That You could also be suffering from hyper mobility snydrome, & I believe You shoud ask if You'll benefit seeing An \"HYPER MOBILITY SNYDROME SPECIALIST & PAIN SPECIALIST\"
\"AS THEY MIGHT REFER YOU TO SPECIAL PHYSIOTHERAPY STRENTHENING EXERCISES & HELP PAIN MANAGERMENT TECHQUIES, & SO ON\"
Julie maybe able to advise on Hyper Mobility Syndrome.
This NHS Hopsital Offers Pain Managerment - General: www.nhs.uk/ServiceDirectories/Pages/hospital.aspx?id=RBT20
&
Full Lists At: www.nhs.uk/ServiceDirectories/Pages/trust.aspx?id=RBT&v=1
I'm amazed they have there own hand/wrist only clinics in orthopeadics & Even Elbow Only Clinics IN orthopeadics, I've not come across that before, LOL
www.ablehere.com/index.php?option=com_bookjoomlas
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Moderators: Scott_1984
Time to create page: 0.250 seconds